Skip to main content

28th March 2019

Mancunion editorial independence threatened by Senate

The amendment could be considered unconstitutional
Mancunion editorial independence threatened by Senate
Photo: Pixabay

A Senate amendment to a policy securing The Mancunion’s funding proposes to enforce a ‘sensitivity reader’ for its editorial team, as well as mandating a quota on the number of BAME editorial staff.

The policy proposal submitted by The Mancunion to Senate, the highest decision-making body in the Students’ Union (SU), was originally intended to protect funding of the paper’s print edition, with the paper’s Deputy Editor-in-Chief Amy Wei expected to support the motion this evening.

Without the policy, the SU trustees, a body which includes the Exec Officers, have the power to pull The Mancunion’s funding.

However, an amendment authored by SU Liberation and Access Officer Sara Khan alongside the Liberation and Access Committee proposes that The Mancunion should not get protected funding unless the paper appoints a ‘sensitivity reader’ and enforces a 45% BAME quota in the editorial team, as well as mandating ‘liberation issues’ and ‘accessible journalism’ training.

The amendment suggestion that the student newspaper accept a ‘sensitivity reader’ appointed by the Liberation and Access committee – to ensure no articles are published which can be perceived as insensitive towards individuals – has been met with opposition from the paper’s management.

The Mancunion’s management team have also branded the proposed quota ‘impossible to achieve’, given the editorial team is made up almost entirely of volunteers. They have also point out that 16% of applicants to the editorial team this year were BAME, and offers were made to 100% of these applicants.

SU bye-laws include a clause protecting The Mancunion‘s editorial independence by effectively enshrining the Editor-in-Chief having ultimate say on editorial issues, meaning it’s unclear if appointing a sensitivity reader chosen by the Liberation and Access Committee could be unconstitutional.

The amendment alleges that The Mancunion engages in ‘unethical journalism’ because articles allegedly at times ‘result in psychological distress, and puts people at risk of being harassed, especially women, who are particularly targeted with death and rape threats through social media.’

The amendment also notes that ‘the make-up of The Mancunion staff should reflect the diversity of our student body in order to properly represent our interests through journalism.’

The Mancunion insists it is an accessible newspaper, accepting contributions and editorial applications from all members of the student body.

The editorial team also argues that it reports extensively on issues relating to diversity, liberation, and activism – pointing out that it curated a themed ‘Misogyny is Hate’ issue with 32 pages of articles discussing women’s issues and the local student-led campaign.

Sara Khan, the Liberation and Access Officer said: “The Liberation and Access committee submitted this amendment because we feel that there have been some articles published by the Mancunion in recent years that have handled information surrounding liberation and diversity poorly.

“We don’t believe that this is malicious or intentional, but that it stems from a lack of diversity in the team, and a lack of training and education surrounding liberation issues. We believe that the proposals outlined in this amendment will only enrich the professional experience and employability prospects of the Mancunion’s journalists, and that this will empower them to further hold the SU and University to account.”

Josh Sandiford

Josh Sandiford

Deputy Editor

More Coverage

Pro-Palestine groups occupy the Roscoe Building

In what is their second occupation of a University building in the last month, Pro-Palestine groups have occupied the Roscoe Building to protest alleged University connections to Israel and its complicity in the conflict in Gaza

Night and Day Cafe’s legal battle comes to an end

The venue can still operate as long as they keep to a reduced noise capacity between 11 pm-3 am during DJ club nights

Nearly half of student gamblers are gambling more than they can afford

The majority of students (60%) had gambled in the past 12 months, although this was a decrease from last year (71%) 

Pro-Palestinian student groups occupy Simon Building in protest against University

Manchester Leftist Action have occupied the Simon Building to protest alleged University connections with Israel, along with students from UoM Rent Strike and Youth Front for Palestine