Skip to main content

12th March 2020

MANIFF 2020: Sweethearts

Karoline Herfurth’s Stockholm syndrome-based romantic comedy Sweethearts is neither romantic nor particularly funny, writes Deputy Film Editor Josh Sandy
MANIFF 2020: Sweethearts

In 1973, Swedish psychologist Nils Bejerot coined the phrase “Stockholm syndrome” to describe a psychological condition in which hostages form positive bonds with their captors.

Karoline Herfurth’s 2019 film Sweethearts takes this phenomenon and uses it as the basis for a ‘romantic comedy’ which is, perhaps unsurprisingly, neither romantic nor particularly funny.

The film follows the story of Franny (Herfurth), a Berlin office worker who suffers from debilitating panic attacks. After being asked to take time off work to deal with them, she is taken hostage by low-level criminal Mel (Hannah Herzsprung) following an ill-fated diamond robbery. This then devolves into a questionably consensual Thelma & Louise-style road-trip as the pair try to evade the police and pay back a Berlin crime gang, whose leader has close personal ties with Mel.

At its best, Herfuth’s film is a tonally confused, but extremely artfully shot crime thriller. Daniel Gottschalk’s cinematography provides glorious wide-angle shots of all aspects of the seedy Berlin underworld and features epic Matrix-style action sequences that The Wachowskis themselves would be proud of.

However, at its worst the film borders on truly offensive. The issues inherent in Franny performing an erotic dance on top of an unconscious, handcuffed police officer to the dulcet tones of Foreigner’s iconic 1984 power ballad ‘I Want to Know What Love Is’, probably don’t need to be explained.

The same can be said for the film’s attitude towards Franny’s panic attacks, which seem to come and go at any given point to suit the film’s plot. The most baffling part of this entire situation is that there are so many opportunities for the film to tackle this issue, but they are consistently squandered. There is one early scene during which the entire conversation revolves around getting help and not suffering through things alone. This is later referenced in terms of helping Mel out of her predicament, but somehow totally avoids any relation to Franny’s. A decision which is, frankly, more than a little bit irresponsible.

As far as female-led crime thrillers go, Sweethearts is a good effort. As far as responsible and principled filmmaking goes, it is far less so.


More Coverage

Poor Things review: Award-winningly outrageous

Exploitative or experimental? Yorgos Lanthimos’ latest has become an instant success, but what is it and why does this cinematic experience deserve every accolade?

Falling in love with the screen: 7 things to watch this Valentine’s

Spend this cold and unforgiving Valentine’s season snuggled up to a film or show, expertly judged and recommended by our globally cultural and renowned experts

The intricacies of Saltburn: Elordi and Keoghan in a harrowing power play

Following the popularity of Saltburn we delve into Emerald Fennell’s stylistic choices through ideas of class and exploration of literature. Saltburn takes what is familiar and turns it into a hedonistic power play

An evening with MASSIVE Cinema at Odeon Great Northern

MASSIVE Cinema projected an exclusive preview of The Iron Claw for young audiences of Manchester at the city’s quaint multiplex, Odeon Great Northern